1807-1813, Cornelius Lansingh (1752-1842)
1814-1816, James Hickok (1757-1823)*
1817-1823, Levi Coley (1777-1859)
1824-1826, Jacob C. Lansing (1790-1852)
1827, Elias Parmelee (1799-1849 or 1740-1840?)
1828-1830, Ebenezer William Walbridge (1779-1856)
l831-1832 Jacob C. Lansing (1790-1852)
1833-1836, John C. Filkin (1786-1847)* (Whig Party)
1837-1839, John Milton Caswell (1777-1857)* (Whig Party)
1840-1843. Jonathan E. Whipple (1806-1866)* (Republican Party)
1844, Edwin Filley (1799-1870) (Whig Party?)
1845, John C. Filkin (1786-1847)* (Whig Party?)
1846, Charles C. Parmelee (1789-1862) (Whig Party?)
1847-1848, Edward P. Pickett*
1849, Thomas H. Fisher (1810-1879)
1850, James I. Adams (1807-1867)
1851, William Bradshaw (1810-1884)
1852-1855, Gerothman W. Cornell (1817-1885) (Whig Party)
1856, Marcus Lucius Filley (1807-1892)
1857-1858, James I. Adams (1807-1867)
1859, Albert E. Powers (1816-1910)
1860, John S. Fake (1800-1876)*
1861, Edward P. Pickett*
1862-1865, Jonathan E. Whipple (1806-1866)* (Republican Party)
1866, William Adam Flack (1824-1901) (Republican Party)
1867-1868, James Dougrey (1831-1913) (Democratic Party?)
1869-1873 Peter B. King (1828-1898) (Republican Party)
1874, Anthony Augustus Peebles (1822-1905) (Democratic Party)
1875-1877, John C. Pushee (1831-1900) (Republican)
1878, Anthony Augustus Peebles (1822-1905) (Democratic Party)
1879-1882, James H. Spotten (1841-1925) (Republican Party)
1882-1887, John M. Chambers (1808-1891) (Republican Party)
1888-1889, Isaac G. Flack (1830-1899)* (Republican Party)
1890-1892, Eugene L. Demers (1842-1912) (Republican Party)
1893, Isaac G. Flack (1830-1899)* (Republican Party), John Roach (Democratic Party)
1894, Hiram W. Gordinier (1861-1922) (Republican Party?)
1895-1899, Eugene L. Demers (1842-1912) (Republican Party)
1900, Frank Halloway Miter (1866-1942) (Republican Party)

Asterisks (*) indicate men who also served at some point as Presidents of the Village of Lansingburgh.

Anderson, George Baker. Landmarks of Rensselaer County. Syracuse, NY: D. Mason & Co., 1897. 399-400. https://archive.org/stream/landmarksofrenss00ande#page/n529/mode/2up
Journal of the Board of Supervisors of Rensselaer County. Troy, NY: Troy Times Art Press. 1901. 398-414 https://babel.hathitrust.org/cgi/pt?id=uiug.30112108222107;view=1up;seq=408